So you've got a big block of Peter’s Caramel sitting in your kitchen. Now what?
If you're wondering how to store Peter’s Caramel, how to cut it, or the best way to melt it, you've come to the right place.
Peter’s Caramel is a versatile, ready-to-use caramel that can be used for caramel apples, popcorn, brownies, cookies, cakes, ice cream, candy, and more. But working with a large block for the first time can raise a few questions.
Here's everything you need to know about storing, cutting, melting, and using Peter’s Caramel.
How Do You Store Peter’s Caramel?
Peter’s Caramel is shelf-stable, making it convenient to keep on hand for baking and candy-making projects.
How to Store Unopened Peter’s Caramel
Keep unopened Peter’s Caramel in a cool, dry place, such as a pantry or cupboard. Avoid storing it near a stove, oven, or other source of heat.
When stored properly, Peter’s Caramel has a shelf life of approximately 12–18 months.
How to Store Opened Peter’s Caramel
Once you've opened the package, protect the unused caramel from air and moisture.
-
Wrap the remaining caramel tightly in plastic wrap.
-
Alternatively, place it in an airtight container.
-
Store it in a cool, dry location.
-
Keep it away from strong-smelling foods, since caramel can absorb surrounding odors.
Should You Refrigerate Peter’s Caramel?
Refrigeration generally isn't necessary when Peter’s Caramel is stored properly at room temperature. If your kitchen is particularly warm, refrigeration may be an option, but the caramel should be allowed to return fully to room temperature before cutting or melting.
If refrigerated or frozen caramel develops some crystallization, that doesn't necessarily mean it has been ruined. Allow it to come back to room temperature before working with it

How Do You Cut Peter’s Caramel?
A large caramel loaf can look intimidating, but you don't need to cut the entire block at once.
The easiest approach is to cut only the amount you need for your recipe and keep the remainder stored properly.
If Your Caramel Is Too Firm to Cut
If the caramel is difficult to cut straight from storage, you can soften it slightly.
Try either of these methods:
-
Let the caramel sit at room temperature for 30–60 minutes.
-
Warm it briefly in the microwave for approximately 5–10 seconds. The goal is to soften the caramel slightly, NOT melt it.
Tips for Cutting Peter’s Caramel
For clean, manageable pieces:
-
Use a sharp chef's knife or bench scraper.
-
Cut the caramel into smaller portions as needed.
-
Lightly coat the knife with cooking spray or a small amount of oil if the caramel sticks.
-
Work on a stable cutting surface.
-
Avoid trying to force a very cold, firm block through the knife.
Cutting the caramel into smaller pieces before melting can also help it heat more evenly.

How Do You Melt Peter’s Caramel?
The best way to melt Peter’s Caramel depends on how much you need. For a large batch, the oven method is convenient. For a smaller amount, the microwave can be faster.
How to Melt Peter’s Caramel in the Oven
The oven method works well when you're melting a larger quantity.
-
Place the desired amount of caramel in a heavy-bottomed pot, Dutch oven, or cocotte.
-
Cover the pot with a lid.
-
Heat at approximately 200°F.
-
Allow the caramel to melt slowly, which can take approximately 1–2 hours for a larger batch.
-
Stir occasionally toward the end of the melting process.
-
Once the caramel is smooth and pourable, it's ready to use.
Slow, gentle heating helps you maintain better control over the caramel and can help prevent overheating.
How to Melt Peter’s Caramel in the Microwave
For smaller batches, the microwave is a convenient option.
-
Cut the caramel into smaller chunks.
-
Place the pieces in a microwave-safe bowl.
-
Heat in 30-second intervals.
-
Stir between intervals.
-
Continue until the caramel is smooth and melted.
Keep a close eye on caramel in the microwave because it can become overheated quickly.
Bonus Tips & Tricks
-
Too thick? Add a little heavy cream to thin it out while melting.
-
Want it firmer for shaping or layering? Use it as-is, no melting needed.
-
Add flavors like sea salt, vanilla, cinnamon, or espresso for a gourmet upgrade.
How Do You Keep Melted Peter’s Caramel Smooth?
Start with gentle heat and avoid overheating the caramel.
If you're preparing caramel for dipping, allow it to melt gradually and stir only occasionally as needed. Excessive stirring can introduce air bubbles, which may affect the appearance of dipped treats.
For larger batches, keeping the caramel covered while it melts can also help maintain a more consistent texture.
What If Peter’s Caramel Is Too Thick?
If melted Peter’s Caramel is thicker than you'd like for a particular application, you can add a small amount of heavy cream while melting to create a softer consistency.
Add the cream gradually and stir until you reach the texture you need.
Keep in mind that the ideal consistency depends on what you're making. A thicker caramel can work well for some fillings and layers, while a thinner caramel is useful for drizzling or certain dipping applications.
What Can You Make With Peter’s Caramel?
Once you've melted or portioned your caramel, there are plenty of ways to use it.
Caramel Apples
Dip apples into melted Peter’s Caramel and add toppings such as chopped nuts, chocolate, sprinkles, or sea salt.
Caramel Popcorn
Melted caramel can be combined with popcorn for a classic sweet-and-salty treat.
Brownies and Cookies
Add caramel as a layer, filling, topping, or drizzle for brownies and cookies.
Cakes and Cupcakes
Use caramel between cake layers, as a filling, or as a finishing drizzle.
Ice Cream
Warm caramel makes an easy topping for ice cream, sundaes, and other frozen desserts.
Pretzels and Candy
Dip pretzels in melted caramel and finish them with chocolate or sea salt. You can also combine caramel with chocolate and other ingredients to create homemade candy.
Peter’s Caramel Troubleshooting
Why is my Peter’s Caramel hard to cut?
Cold caramel can become firm and difficult to portion. Allow it to sit at room temperature for 30–60 minutes or soften it briefly before cutting.
Why is my melted caramel too thick?
The consistency can depend on temperature and application. For a thinner caramel, try adding a small amount of heavy cream while melting and stir until smooth.
Why did my caramel develop crystals?
Refrigerating or freezing caramel can contribute to crystallization. Allow it to return completely to room temperature before cutting or melting.
Why does my melted caramel have bubbles?
Excessive stirring can introduce air into melted caramel. For dipping applications, stir gently and avoid unnecessary agitation.
Can I melt the entire block of Peter’s Caramel?
Yes, particularly when you're preparing a large batch. However, if you only need a small amount, it's usually more practical to cut off what you need and store the remaining caramel properly.
Final Thoughts
Peter’s Caramel is designed to make caramel desserts easier. Once you know how to store, cut, and melt the caramel, you can keep a block on hand and use just what you need for your next baking or candy-making project.
From caramel apples and popcorn to brownies, cookies, cakes, pretzels, and ice cream, there are plenty of ways to put Peter’s Caramel to work in your kitchen.
Keep it stored properly, cut what you need, melt it gently, and start creating.
