We’ve all been there. You stocked up on a big 5 lb. block of Peter’s Caramel (because honestly, who can resist caramel season?), dipped your apples and pretzels to your heart’s content… and now you’ve still got plenty left. Don’t let that sweet, golden goodness go to waste—let’s put it to good use.
Here are seven easy, crowd-pleasing caramel recipes that will make you the hero of every fall gathering (or at least your own kitchen). Bonus: they’re beginner-friendly and perfect for cozy baking days.
1. Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies
If chocolate chip cookies are good, then caramel chocolate chip cookies are next-level. Melt Peter’s Caramel into the dough or tuck little chunks inside for gooey caramel pockets that surprise with every bite.
👉 Get the recipe
2. Salted Caramel Popcorn
Perfect for movie nights, game days, or snacking straight from the bowl. A quick drizzle of melted Peter’s Caramel, a sprinkle of flaky sea salt, and boom—gourmet popcorn without leaving the couch.
👉 Get the recipe
3. Salted Caramel Rice Krispies
Classic rice krispie treats just got an upgrade. Swirl melted caramel through those marshmallow-y layers for a chewy, buttery twist that’ll have everyone asking for seconds.
👉 Get the recipe
4. Chocolate & Caramel Turtles
These sweet little bites are dangerously easy to make. Melt Peter’s Caramel over pecans, top with chocolate, and let it set. They’re the perfect holiday treat—or weekday pick-me-up.
👉 Get the recipe
5. Chocolate-Dipped Sea Salt Caramels
This one’s a showstopper. Slice Peter’s Caramel into squares, dip them in rich chocolate, and finish with a pinch of sea salt. They look fancy, taste amazing, and make the best homemade gifts.
👉 Get the recipe
6. Sea Salt Caramel Coconut Cookies
If you love chewy cookies with a little texture, these are for you. The toasted coconut pairs perfectly with smooth caramel—basically fall in a bite.
👉 Get the recipe
7. Midnight Snack Straight from the Block
Let’s be real. Sometimes the best caramel recipe… isn’t a recipe at all. Slice off a little piece, pop it in your mouth, and enjoy. Zero dishes, zero regrets.
Why We Love Peter’s Caramel
Peter’s Caramel melts like a dream, holds its shape beautifully, and makes every treat taste just a little more special. It’s a total fall baking essential.
And here’s the sweet deal: our Peter’s Caramel sale ends October 31st—so if you want to try these recipes (and trust us, you do), now’s the time to grab a block.
